You look just like her
But you don't fool me
'Cause I know her sweet love
Was more than a dream
How did I miss it when you took her place
There's not a trace of her love on your face

So please tell me who are you
And where is the girl I knew
She said her love was true
You're breaking my heart
Something she'd never do
Who are you

Go back where you came from
And send her back here
Use the same magic
That made her disappear
I want the girl who thought I hung the moon
The last thing I want is some stranger saying we're through

So please tell me who are you
And where is the girl I knew
She said her love was true
You're saying goodbye
Something she'd never do
Who are you

Where is the girl I knew
You're breaking my heart
Something she'd never do
Who are you
Who are y